Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: More Televised Winter Baseball, Please

News Roundup

-P- The Pirates continue to be contenders... in the race to pay Jeff Suppan a whole lot of money. If this is where the Pirates' entire offseason budget is going to go, color me unimpressed. First and foremost, the Pirates need offense, and anyway, Suppan is very unlikely to continue to be a very effective starter if he plays with the Pirates. He doesn't strike batters out and he depends way too heavily on his defense. The Pirates shouldn't be shelling out $40 or $50 million to a pitcher who won't look good with their poor defense behind him.

-P- The Giants added another Padre (after already grabbing Dave Roberts and Bruce Bochy) by signing Ryan Klesko to a one-year, $1.75 million deal that could be worth up to $2 million more if Klesko stays on the field. Some Pirates fans worried that the Bucs would sign Klesko, and it's a good thing we didn't, but it's easy to forget that he posted a .399 OBP as recently as 2004. For the right team, Klesko can be a huge bargain at $1.75 million.

Unfortunately, the Giants aren't that team. They can't really play Klesko in the outfield because he's brutal and because they already have better players in Barry Bonds, Randy Winn and Dave Roberts to play there. Todd Linden could also use some playing time in the outfield. They could play Klesko at first base, where he's at least passable, but Rich Aurilia rightly will get the lion's share of the at bats there after his excellent season in 2006. The Giants' other first baseman, Mark Sweeney (yet another former Padre!), is a lefty like Klesko and is probably just as good as Klesko at this point. If I were running the Giants, I'd play Klesko or Sweeney at first and Aurilia at third against righties, only allowing the execrable Pedro Feliz to play against lefties. Given that the Giants recently agreed to pay Feliz $5 million in 2007, though, I doubt that's the conclusion they'll reach. Anyway, my point is that Klesko doesn't really make much sense for the Giants. Even as Bonds insurance, he's no good, because he's recently been one of the worst defensive outfielders I've ever seen.

-P- The Twins signed Rondell White to a one-year deal worth $2.75 million that includes an option and bonuses that could bring the total value of the deal to $8.5 million. White is a corner outfielder and DH who had a .276 OBP last year. Fans might be tempted to look for hope in the fact that he had a .424 OPS in the first half and an .892 OPS in the second, and that at least some of White's spectacularly poor play in the first half was due to recurring injury problems. But a .276 OBP from a 30-something player is still a .276 OBP from a 30-something player, and it's not safe to assume the injuries won't continue - one doesn't earn the nickname "Ron DL" for phonetic reasons alone. It must be tough for Terry Ryan to compete in the free agent market, but I'd still like to think a GM with his reputation should make transactions more inspired than this one.

Comment 6 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Jeff Suppan etc.
The Pirates don`t need him. What makes them think that he would be anything other than an overpriced .500 pitcher for them? How many times in the past decade or so have we paid way too much money for some veteran FA that hasn`t made any difference on the field? Quite a few of them have actually hurt the Pirates with their bad attitudes/poor work ethics.
The Bucs have plenty of pitching depth to start the season. I expect the young starters to be much better in 2007. They have plenty of quality arms in the bullpen. I further expect more overall production from the everyday players currently on the roster. I say stay the course from now and use the pitching depth for necessary trades after April-if they can prove for the first time since `92 that they have a chance at a winning record.    

by patthatt on Dec 20, 2006 9:59 AM EST reply actions  

Suppan
Jeff Sackman has a piece up at The Hardball Times ("The Mid-Rotation Starter of Your Dreams") in which he points out that acquiring Suppan would make a difference to the Pirates of about two wins. I believe the word he used for spending $10M a year to improve from 67 wins to 69 was "insane."

That's also what Suppan would have to be to take an offer from the Bucs over anything even remotely similar from an actual contender. I don't think we emphasize nearly enough here that no free agent in his right mind would want to play for the Pirates.

by bucdaddy on Dec 20, 2006 10:30 AM EST reply actions  

Follow the dollar
I disagree with that concept.  I think most free agents will go for the highest dollar amount.  It's not the only factor, and for some it's not the highest factor, but overall, that factor guides the decision.
azibuck

by azibuck on Dec 20, 2006 1:12 PM EST up reply actions  

Easy to deduce
Always remember that people remember the most recent accomplishments first (duh). Therefore, Suppan is not just a mediocre pitcher who will likely underperform his contract. He is a World Series veteran starting pitcher and he won games in the playoffs. He is the veteran anchor that Pirates say they want (whether he is or not - again, look at it from the Pirate perspective).

I would be very surprised if the Pirates didn't sign them unless they aren't going to spend any money and it has all been a charade. If the Pirates don't spend money and with the Steelers not in the playoffs, it could get ugly quick - therefore I expect a least one crazy veteran contract just to say, look we signed Player Retread who will help us in some small way.

by Greg Schuler on Dec 20, 2006 10:56 AM EST reply actions  

"veteran anchor"
The Pirates are very good at finding these, especially when they're trying to cast off.

by WTM on Dec 20, 2006 1:02 PM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about Pittsburgh Pirates.

Managers

Charlie_small Charlie Wilmoth

Editors

18470r_small Vlad

Authors

Davidtodd_small David Todd

Img_1692_small WTM

Mark_profile_pic_small MarkInDallas