On Dave Holliday and the Rockies' Christianity

The Post-Gazette reports that Colorado scout Dave Holliday - uncle of Matt - is interested in being the Pirates' scouting director.

If he were selected, I'd have some serious reservations. First of all, Holliday has been with the Rockies a long time (at least since 1998), and the Rockies have been a poor organization most of that time. Their drafting record since then has been spotty, too - in 1998, they had three first round draft picks, and they took Matt Roney, Choo Freeman and Jeff Winchester. In 2000, they took Matt Harrington with the seventh overall pick. More recent top picks like Jayson Nix (2001) and Chris Nelson (2004) have been slow to develop, and two years later the Rockies took Greg Reynolds, who was kind of like the Bryan Bullington of the '06 draft, with the second overall pick. Reynolds, a low-upside pick to begin with, had shoulder surgery in August. In 2000, the Rockies threw nearly $3 million at second-rounder Jason Young, who completely flamed out. They also gave a $2.2 million bonus to Chin-Hui Tsao, who hasn't done anything, in 1999.

Obviously, every team has scouting successes and failures, and the Rockies deserve credit for Jeff Francis, Troy Tulowitzki, Brad Hawpe, Garrett Atkins, and so on. But, given the high draft picks they've had, their record is average at best, and players like Reynolds are exactly the sorts of picks the Pirates should avoid at all costs. If I were interviewing Holliday, I'd want to know what he'd do differently from the Rockies. Remember, the Rockies finished below .500 in six consecutive years before this one. They are not a great organization, no matter what happens this year.

Saying this probably isn't going to make me very popular, but whatever: if I were interviewing Holliday, I'd also want to know exactly what he thinks about this:

This, to me, sounds like a very dumb and unfair way to run a baseball team. The Rockies repeatedly claim that they're open to other views - if they didn't, I assume they could be sued - but from other aspects of the article and from Sweeney's comments, it doesn't sound like that's the case, and at the very least, it sounds like an uncomfortable environment for a non-Christian. Whatever you think of Christianity, the Pirates can't afford to pass on players who can help them, regardless of religion.

Now take a look at this article:  

That's discrimination on the basis of religion. In my view, it's wrong. I don't want to say any more about it here because this isn't a political blog, but I don't want the Pirates to become a team that discriminates on the basis of religion, which is what Dan O'Dowd has just admitted to doing with the Rockies.

Furthermore, and maybe more relevant to the subject of this blog, this is an extremely dumb policy for baseball reasons alone. It's just as dumb as ignoring the Latin American free agent market the way the Pirates have, for example.

Speaking of which:

In fairness, Willy Taveras is also Dominican, and several of the Rockies' relievers are non-white. But this is still a strikingly white team. All their stars are white.

It's worth pointing out, again, that the Rockies had six consecutive losing seasons before this one (including two after their franchise-conversion following the Denny-Neagle-with-a-hooker episode three years ago), and it's remarkable to me that instead of seeing that and coming to the conclusion that their policy hasn't led to the best baseball, or the conclusion that they've finally found some good young players with which to surround Todd Helton, they now think God is finally rewarding them now that they've played really well for a month. Their approach raises obvious questions about the mistakes they've made - did they pick Reynolds instead of Evan Longoria or Andrew Miller or Clayton Kershaw or Tim Lincecum or Travis Snider because those players didn't have the right religious beliefs?

In my view, this is no way to run a team, both for baseball-related and ethical reasons, and if I were interviewing Dave Holliday, I would want to know exactly what his role in this policy has been. The scouting director is obviously extremely important in determining which players join the organization and which don't. The Pirates simply can't afford to skip out on players who don't happen to have their preferred religious beliefs. And, furthermore, they shouldn't.