Minor League Roundup
With a couple weeks' worth of baseball out of the way, enough has happened in the minors for the results to mean... well, at least a little something.
Class AAA Indianapolis: Luis Cruz is off to a good start since losing his big-league roster spot to Delwyn Young, but he's staying cool about it:
The Pirates should be happy Cruz has such a level head on him. He told me that Brian Bixler is the next everyday shortstop in Pittsburgh and Cruz wants to be their utility guy. It's unusual to find someone who understands his role and accepts it.
I doubt Bixler will be an everyday player in the majors, but he's off to a great start too, hitting .340 AVG / .440 OBP / .532 SLG. Andrew McCutchen has been brilliant, hitting a remarkable five triples en route to a .630 slugging percentage. Maybe Steve Pearce should have sat out the first two weeks--four of his seven hits this season came in the last two games. Before that, he couldn't hit anything. After a hot start, Neil Walker is hitting .220/.259/.440, showing about the same blend of power and out-making that plagued him last year. I'll take Andy LaRoche right now, thanks. The most interesting pitchers have been Daniel McCutchen, Tom Gorzelanny and Evan Meek, but they're all walking too many batters. McCutchen has 20 strikeouts in 16 innings, but he's also allowed nine walks and three homers, and he has twice as many flyball outs as groundball outs. That won't play in the majors. He really needs to work on keeping the ball down.
Class AA Altoona: Lots of slow starts here, from Jose Tabata to Jamie Romak to Steve Lerud, but Jim Negrych has been on his game so far, at least at the plate. If Negrych could play shortstop, he'd instantly become one of the best utility players in all of baseball, but unfortunately, he can barely handle second. He'll probably hit wherever he goes--it's his glove that will hold him back. Brad LIncoln has pitched pretty well; it still amazes me how little Pirates fans talk about him. But he will soon be 24. Michael Crotta is already 24, but he's been solid in his first two starts. With his sinker and past troubles pitching to lefties, he may eke out a big-league career as a sort of ROOGY ("righty one-out guy," which isn't usually the sort of pitcher big-league teams can spend a roster spot on--"righty two-out guy," maybe?). Jeff Sues has struck out 14 batters in 10.7 innings; he's 26 in June and pitched 43 innings for Altoona last year, so one would think the Pirates would be looking to move him to Indianapolis soon. Danny Moskos is still the stupidest waste of a draft pick of all time.
Class A+ Lynchburg: Pedro Alvarez is still doing fine, with an .868 OPS. 2008 third-rounder Jordy Mercer is quietly having a solid season despite being promoted aggressively. The Pirates had the bright idea to make a starter out of Ronald Uviedo, whose excellence in Hickory's bullpen last year earned him a spot on the 40-man roster, and Uviedo has responded, posting a 1.20 ERA in three starts and shutting down Frederick yesterday. It probably doesn't mean much, but 2008 14th-rounder Mike Colla (not to be confused with Crotta, above) has eight strikeouts in 5.7 innings, to go with a bunch of ground balls.
Class A West Virginia: 2008 draft picks Chase D'Arnaud (a shortstop) and Calvin Anderson (a first baseman) have both hit like crazy so far. Catcher Andrew Walker has a .455 OBP, but that might be due to him being 23 and having a fairly advanced approach at the plate. He only has a .394 SLG so far, and he needs to prove he can do more than just take a pitch. From a prospect standpoint, the pitching at West Virginia is awful. The most interesting performances so far have come from Rudy Owens and Gabriel Alvarado, who are fortunately among the few pitchers at that level young enough to be prospects. They're both starting, so they bear watching for now. 2007 14th-rounder Kyle McPherson made his 2009 debut on Monday and was great, striking out four batters in three innings. He's only 21 and was one of the few good performers at State College last year, so he, too, is somewhat intriguing.
40 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
What a strange night at Indy...
Indians losing 4-3 after 6. Luis Cruz is playing RF (after playing 1B last night)…and has THREE outfield assists already…one at 2B, one at 3B, and one at the plate. Steven Pearce has hit a HR…and is 6 for 13 in his last 48 hours. He had an Andy LaRoche start at Indy…and has now made it to the Mendoza line.
Bixler has a couple more hits and is hitting over .350…and Cutch with a hit and RBI.
I'll bet
SEC infields are better than Carolina League infields.
‘Sides, we’ll need a first baseman once Adam gets traded.
I'm not as upbeat
… as Bucdaddy, and how often can a person say that?
I saw Pedro play a couple of games at Lynchburg and he didn’t appear to have very good hands. There was also this peculiar play: With runners on first and second, Pedro hustled in to field a bunt and left 3B uncovered. (SS was covering second.) Fortunately, it was foul. The scorer there also credited a couple of obvious errors as hits (not on balls to Pedro), so if that’s a general practice it might be worse than I think. Obviously it’s a small sample, though.
This should not be a surprise.
A lot of analysts were projecting him as a 1B during the draft, and it’s certainly been my assumption all along. He doesn’t have a 3B’s body, and he didn’t look great there in the college footage I saw.
We’re lucky that he has the bat to be productive at 1B.
Sure, but...
…the graveyards of the minors are littered with the bones of guys who were supposed to be top bats, but didn’t hit. Back when we drafted Mark Merchant, there were people saying that it was six of one and a half dozen of the other whether you’d do better to have him or Griffey.
In that sense, it’s fortunate that his bat has been (up to this point) as good as advertised.
GAH! Tell me again why we didn't draft Smoak?
Was it that it was possible Pedro could stick at 3B? Because Smoak can field too. You can treat this as rhetorical if you want, it’s not like Smoak went 3rd, he was bypassed by other teams too, but I just think it was a mistake to let a hitter like that go by.
Possible? Sure.
I didn’t think that he would, but I’m not Christ on the throne. And there were a fair number of scouts who thought he’d be able to stick as at least a mediocre defensive 3B. I just didn’t agree with them.
Defensively, Smoak probably can’t handle anything beyond 1B, but he’s very good there.
Great post
Never seem to have enough time to keep up with all the Pirates minor league news. This was a great summary.
I made most of my life decisions at a Foghat concert... I stand by them.
by Chester J Lampwick on Apr 23, 2009 9:47 PM EDT reply actions
Dejan does a quick recap of everyone’s games in his blog that is quite useful. Also, I write one up that is very similar to his (only mine is up earlier).
Like you said, it’s sometimes hard to keep up with them, that’s basically the main reason why I do one. Keeps me on the ball.
Also, Charlie, what do you think the Pirates will do with Negrych? There’s no doubt the guy can hit. He’s done it everywhere. The thing that seems to be holding him back is his glove. But at what time does the hitting just push him up? I gotta think that if he’s batting above .300 by the end of this season, he’s either in Pittsburgh or on someone else’s ML roster by next April. He seems to be too good a hitting infielder to keep him in the minors much longer to learn how to field.
by northsidenotch on Apr 23, 2009 11:19 PM EDT up reply actions
Yeah I’ve read Dejan’s before and it’s pretty good and I bookmarked your site.
Every year I say that I will pay more in-depth attention to the Pirates minor league system but I never seem to keep that promise.
I made most of my life decisions at a Foghat concert... I stand by them.
by Chester J Lampwick on Apr 24, 2009 12:21 AM EDT up reply actions
I haven't seen him play since college,
and a lot of people who know their stuff really hate his glove (see: Vlad). Regardless, Negrych has to be able to fake second enough to play it at the MLB level if he can hit a consistent .300/.370/.420, which I think he can.
Magadan-style PH
Ten year career coming off the bench. I don’t think his glove plays anywhere, but a guy with good contact and a little pop is always nice to have as an ace in the hole.
I definitely agree
Keppinger is the better fielder. Way better. But their paths seem to be going in similar directions in that both hit the ball for a very high average when in the Pirates organization without the team seeming to high on them.
by northsidenotch on Apr 24, 2009 6:21 PM EDT up reply actions
DL, being the idiot he was, had no regard for Keppinger, but I’m not sure the same is true now with Negrych. I guess we’ll see. Even though I don’t think he can field well enough to start in the majors, I think he could be a very useful player. DL would have just looked at the bad glove and figured he needed a veteran for the bench. NH hopefully will give him a shot if he keeps hitting.
I've said it before...
That’s exactly who comes to my mind.
by northsidenotch on Apr 24, 2009 6:18 PM EDT up reply actions
WTM is right
Similar to Keppinger in a lot of ways, but significantly less defense. Negrych is kind of an infielder the same way Bobby Bonilla was a third baseman: definitionally only.
DH? Vlad
This is more of a general question, but couldn’t an AL team grab a couple of Negrych types and see if one can keep hitting and walking all the way up? He’s got more power than, e.g., Reggie Willits, and is a better hitter. Willits is more like Nyjer. Seems like you might be able to develop a .775+ OPS type DH by taking flyers on guys like Negrych, or at least not pigeonholing them as not good enough. Would probably need just enough power to keep teams honest, but that could be Negrych. Maybe resources could be better spent, but why not have a cheap pre-arb bat in your lineup at DH every day?
Teams seem very reluctant to just hand DH to a rookie.
Look at Butler with KC. He’s got significantly more bat than Negrych, and even less glove, but the team still took more than a year to just sit back and let him settle into the spot.
Negrych would also probably get limited opportunities as a DH because he doesn’t have a huge offensive ceiling. He’ll probably be a fairly productive hitter (maybe a Bill Mueller type), but almost certainly won’t be a lineup anchor, and when choosing a DH a lot of teams seem to go for ceiling over floor.
Negrych
Are his skillz at the plate something that would play better in the AL? Could he hit enough to be a DH there?
Mike Colla
For what it’s worth, I recall last year after the draft that Colla was picked by at least a couple of outlets to be a possible sleeper in the Pirates draft class. I believe I saw that in BA, at least.
Perry Hill
Maybe Negrych would benefit by spending time with Perry Hill. You have to credit Perry with Andy’s turnaround. I would take a hitter with average glove anyday. Maybe we could package Freddy with Adam and platoon Young and Negrych with Hill working with both of them on the side?
Unfortunately...
…I just don’t think that Negrych has the physical tools to be more than a below-average infield defender. Good instruction can only do so much. But hey, what the hell, give it a shot. Hill’s pretty sharp.
If I were going to try an experiment with him, I might slip him a little OF time, to see whether he can be a four-corners backup/emergency starter like Ron Coomer.
Vlad
Do you think it would be a good idea to start getting Jim Negrych some games in left and right to improve his chances for the majors?
Negrych may very well fall victim to what happened to a guy like Rick Short: 12 pitchers on a team’s 25-man roster doesn’t tend to leave space these days for players like them.
As for Pedro Alvarez, your spot on with your comments. I remember you being generous and calling him “broad across the beam” last year. He’ll play 1st base in Pittsburgh.
Big props for trying Uviedo in the rotation.
I asked Perrotto about that over the offseason, and he said he didn’t think they would, but with as many quality pitches as he has it always seemed like a waste not to give him a look there.
Also good to see Pearce heating up, and Mercer bouncing back from a rough stint in rookie ball.
Pedro at 1B
Alvarez will be our everyday 1B once Adam is gone.
JOOSE
If this is 1999, Nyjer comes into camp 20 pounds heavier talking about his crazy off season strength program with his new trainer, hits 20 home runs and this conversation never happens.
Oh and I’m kidding. He doesn’t strike me as the kind of guy who would do it but we said that about lots of guys who let us down. Any way my point is there were a lot of guys whose lack of power, at least compared to their peers kept them from making the next step and suddenly found 15-20 homers in a fedex from Mexico. So nobody freak out and rant about me suggesting NYJER start sticking needles in his butt.
McLouth is The Trouth
While we're at it
I like to imagine this whole team on roids
Nyjer is a poor man’s Grady Sizemore. Freddy has Nate’s power, Nate has 30 HR’s Doumit is back form injury in 4 weeks. We’d be awesome! Someone get me Victor Conte on the phone like 5 minutes ago!
McLouth is The Trouth
A lot of people overestimate the impact of steroids.
I mean, Manny Alexander took steroids. They found them in his car and everything.
Manny Alexander had 15 career home runs in 1,387 career plate appearances.
GTrain, We Might Never See ...
the names of Nyjer Morgan and Grady Sizemore used in the same sentence ever again.

by 


















