Pirates Have "Inside Track" on Dominican Prospect Miguel Angel Sano
The Pirates have set their sights on shortstop Miguel Angel Sano, who's supposed to be one of the better talents to emerge from the Dominican recently. Since the Post-Gazette is running a big article on it, it's probably legit. Sano's bonus could be over $3 million, so, as Dejan Kovacevic points out on his blog, signing Sano could be an even bigger deal than whoever the Pirates pick in the June draft, since the draft isn't exactly loaded with talent this year.
Obviously, there are big differences between signing a 16-year-old Dominican kid (and the Pirates ran a DNA test that confirmed that Sano is, in fact, 16) and drafting a player out of college or even high school. There's an enormous amount of uncertainty in signing a 16-year-old, simply because he can't just skip the lowest rungs of the minor league system the way a promising draftee can. For example, the A's signed Michael Inoa out of the Dominican for $4.25 million last year, and he hasn't even played in the minors yet. If you're a fan of a team who signs someone like Sano, you just have to forget about him for a while, because he won't be anywhere near the majors anytime soon. But Sano is so young, and apparently so talented, that one can imagine anything is possible.
The Post-Gazette reports that the Pirates have the "inside track" on Sano--he's worked out for them privately, and he and his agent are close with Pirates Latin American scouting director Rene Gayo. In the past, the Pirates haven't paid multimillion-dollar bonuses (or anything near them) for Latin American amateurs, but Gayo's increased budget for Latin signings last year, the recent opening of an improved Dominican academy for Pirates prospects, and a thin June draft all suggest that a serious play for Sano could be possible. The Pirates spent a ton of money on the draft last year and have said they won't be cheap this year, but since there isn't a Pedro Alvarez to soak up a $6 million bonus, it's possible they'll have extra money left over if their draft budget is the same or has increased.
I know nothing about Sano that the P-G and random Googling haven't told me, so I have no idea whether he's worth $3 or $4 million or if that money might be better spent on signability players late in the draft (like Robbie Grossman and Quinton Miller last year). I do know there's a tremendous amount of uncertainty involved in signing a 16-year-old for that much money, but I also know this is no time for the Pirates to be conservative. Bold moves will be needed to fix a franchise that still lacks the talent base it needs to contend, and signing Sano would be nothing if not bold. That's not the same as saying it would be the right move, but it sure would be exciting.
23 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Wow
Here’s an excerpt from Dejan’s story linked above:
Statistics are scarce in the Dominican amateur ranks, so Sano’s prowess is evaluated almost entirely by scouting on sandlots. The consensus is that Sano will move to a corner outfield spot once he turns professional, probably right field to take advantage of the arm. The consensus of his offensive potential ranges from excellent to extraordinary.
“Based on what I’ve seen and heard from talent evaluators, his upside is that he’s Albert Pujols in Hanley Ramirez’s body,” Plummer said of the stars of the St. Louis Cardinals and Florida Marlins, respectively. “He might not stay at short the way Ramirez has, but he’s been compared to Pujols’ bat because of a short, compact swing with lots of power.”
That might sound like agent-speak, but the praise for Sano was equally effusive from others in the industry interviewed for this story, none of whom wished to go on the record in advance of the July 2 signing period.
If the Pirates somehow pull this off, it — and not drafting Pedro Alvarez — might be looked back upon as the turning point for the franchise.
It’s probably best not to get your hopes up, but, really, words can’t describe how big this would be.
I would like this move.
If Nutting is serious about fixing the Pirates, this is the kind of move Huntington needs to be allowed to make or at the very least compete on. $4 million is a lot of money for a 16 year old who’s basically just played sandlot ball in the DR. But if other teams are as high on this guy as the Pirates are, maybe this is the time and place to open the wallet.
Personally, based on the Post-Gazette article, I would be very happy with the front office if they get it done.
Launch the new Dominican facility
This is pure marketing. They recently built a Dominican facility. What better way to promote it within that country than to sign a young player to “whores and blow” money? Agents and talent evaluators will be more inclined to send a player to the new facility for try-outs and training… it’s a good move, whether the kid pans out or not.
Sounds great and I’ll be very enthused if they sign this kid, but I have to roll my eyes when his agent compares him to Albert Pujols. Nobody, but nobody, compares to Pujols. There isn’t another hitter in the game, not A-Rod or Manny or anybody, who’s half as scary as Albert.
Me too. (rolling eyes, that is)
Of course his agent’s job is to get the most amount of money for him. So it’s probably just him trying to milk a few more hundred thousand bucks from whatever team signs him…
by IAPiratesFan on May 15, 2009 11:22 AM EDT up reply actions
Looking at BR’s comparables through Pujols’ age, we’ve got 8 HoF-ers (I’m including Griffey). And those HoF-ers weren’t exactly marginal candidates. So, yeah, I’d be pleased if he was half the hitter that Pujols is.
by wickethewok on May 15, 2009 11:30 AM EDT up reply actions
Until Albert is caught...?
Let’s face it, there are no sacred cows left in baseball.
by RDV across the sea on May 15, 2009 2:10 PM EDT up reply actions
Does anybody other than newspaper columnists...
…actually care about drugs in baseball at this point?
The Dominican vs the Pirates
The way I see it, the Pirates have almost cornered themselves into signing Cano. They opened the facility, are trying to make a splash there, and are trying to convince fans like me (the ones that have become cynics after all the years of losing) that they are serious about improving. That could actually be a good thing, as it looks (errr… pardon me… sounds) like the guy is a serious prospect.
The way I see it, the Pirates brass will show their true colors when Freddy, Nate, Ryan, Paul, etc. will near the end of their contracts, while the so called future stars are coming up. Will the Pirates continue to be the farm system of the Yankees, etc, or will they be REALLY SERIOUS about being competitive and not give their best players away?
To finish, I believe last year’s draft was a seriously good one for the Pirates. Some hope is there (on my part). However, those people need to do more to convince me they are serious about being competitive and taking the Pirates franchise to where it once was; one of the best franchises in baseball history.
by Pirate in Montana on May 15, 2009 11:33 AM EDT reply actions
For the Pirates brass showing true colors...
what would you want them to do with Freddy? And they already signed the other three to extensions, but I guess you’re referencing at the end of those contracts.
by hisjazziness on May 15, 2009 1:02 PM EDT up reply actions
Yes, I was...
… making reference to what may take place at or right before the end of the contracts for the other players.
You ask a very good question that could be answered in many, many ways.
Keeping in mind that Freddy was on ESPN just recently, I must confess that I wanted the Pirates to keep him at third base. The reason is that I don’t see him as a good defensive second baseman. O.K., let me not go in circles any more.
Here it goes. In my opinion, the Pirates should keep Freddy Sanchez until they can find a better option. At this time, it does not look like they have one. They seem to have one good prospect at AA, but the guy just seems to get hurt all the time (Ford?). I would like the Pirates to keep Sanchez until the end of his contract, including next season. He is not my favorite player, and I don’t like how he uses the Manny Sanguillen approach to hitting, but when he is healthy he can hit those doubles almost at will.
INCOMING,
RUN FOR COVER, PIRATE IN MONTANA,
RETREAT!
P.S. – I would love the Pirates to be as aggresive as the Penguins are. Do Mario and Shero know anaything about baseball? I like the “Rooney way” too.
by Pirate in Montana on May 15, 2009 2:27 PM EDT reply actions
Mario and Shero
They know about running a team poorly for a few years, poorly enough to luck into winning the lottery 3 out of 4 years (or something like it) and getting the #2 pick in the other draft, where the #2 guy had as much potential as the #1 guy.
And, they work in a sport where the draft is much more predictive of success.
I don’t mean this to sound as negative as it sounds.
by hisjazziness on May 15, 2009 2:54 PM EDT up reply actions
I don’t think the Pirates=Pens=Steelers analogy is really a good one to use. The Pens (as hisjazziness pointed out) got lucky with drafts and there had decent teams which they were able to make better at the trade deadline (Hossa, Guerin, etc.) which is what the Brewers did last season and hopefully something the Pirates do someday. And football is a totally different sport with the salary cap, etc.
Oh but I totally agree that a team in the Pirates position needs to be aggressive, I just think they should be aggressive in the minors and in drafting as opposed to signing free agents.
I made most of my life decisions at a Foghat concert... I stand by them.
by Chester J Lampwick on May 15, 2009 4:15 PM EDT up reply actions
Good Comments. Thanks.
Well…, I don’t think Mario and Shero were the ones responsible to the Penguins losing ways. Of course, they have benefited from their drafts. However, they aggresively signed their best players to long-term contracts and made a huge offer to Hossa. The mid-season trades the last two seasons have been awesome in my opinion. The Pirates have not received the memo yet. The point made was that the Penguins and Steelers “administrations” work hard at making the franchises serious and respectable.
If only I could do a fast forward to the time in which the “core” of the current Pirates that are worth anything will be given away for peanuts… or lost to free agency. Beware! Sarcasm ahead. I am sure they will have a great draft that year too, and open a baseball academy in Antartica or something. The sarcasm was not intended at any of you. That was the only way I could find to share the way I see the Pirates working. I hope you understand.
To finish my point/rant for today (I will let you have the final word if you choose to respond) I will say the following. The way I see it, the Pirates are in another “five-year cycle.” The point is that this looks to me like “The Neverending Story.” The serious teams have/make budgets to balance drafts and free agents, not the Pirates.
by Pirate in Montana on May 15, 2009 5:14 PM EDT reply actions
I don’t think we should sign this kid for $4M unless he can already hit major league pitching. Kids develop at various rates around that age. Just because he is advanced now doesn’t mean that his ceiling is necessarily that much higher. With 16 year olds it’s all about projection but there is no way to project his physical development during the next 4 years with enough certainty to warrant a $3-4M bonus. Just look at Pedro Alvarez, he was a “safe bet” to be a great major league hitter, and he is currently hitting 225 at Lynchburg. Not saying that Alvarez is a bust, just illustrating the inherent difficulty in projection.
With 3 or 4 million dollars we could sign 10 guys who are the calibre of Cayones(?) who was our top signing last year. In other words, we could probably get 10 of the top 50-100 latin american prospects for $4M and that seems like a much wiser way to spend our money, since the odds are so much better that one of those 10 good prospects will turn into a good player, as opposed to putting all of our chips behind one guy.
That’s a good point, how would that signing effect the overall budget for drafting and player development? This could be an interesting test for Mr. Nutting. Will he pony up 4 million for Sano and continue to sign guys like Cayones?
I, for one, still hope the Pirates sign this kid despite the possible budget implications.
I made most of my life decisions at a Foghat concert... I stand by them.
by Chester J Lampwick on May 15, 2009 10:53 PM EDT up reply actions
I'll believe it when I see it...
Signing Mr. Sano would be a fantastic move for the Buccos, but I just don’t see them winning this thing. It would be a fantastic move to promote their new Dominican academy. If the Pirates are going to compete long term, they have to develop young talent from all over. Sano would be a great start.
On another topic, Neal Huntington isn’t going to prove himself in the next round of negotiations with Ryan, Nate, and Freddy. The fact is the Bucs are no where near competing and the best course of action is to build long term. Those guys should probably be traded when their value can be maxed out for prospects. There is almost no talent in the system (especially pitching talent) and until the system can be rebuilt and produce a solid stream of talent there’s no point in throwing money at big league players. The Buccos are never going to have a payroll to compete with the big boys, so they’re going to have to take the Marlin-type approach and part with guys when they’re at peek value in order to constantly restock the farm system to produce new young talent.
I’d love to see them sign Sano, it would give us some hope. And hope is really all we have these days.
I didn't RTFA
but I have no clue how a DNA test could “prove” someone’s age. Unless you could maybe prove who his birth mother is and you could independently confirm that she’s only 32 or something.
I suspect Dejan conflated two things there:
A DNA test to ensure that he is who he says he is (i.e. the biological child of his parents) and a bone age test (similar to this one?)to approximate his DOB. The latter has a fairly high error bar on it, so he could easily be 17 (or 15) and come up clean, but it does probably rule out him secretly being 24 or anything really crazy like that.
Crap, broken tag.
Let’s try that again:
A DNA test to ensure that he is who he says he is (i.e. the biological child of his parents) and a bone age test (similar to this one?) to approximate his DOB. The latter has a fairly high error bar on it, so he could easily be 17 (or 15) and come up clean, but it does probably rule out him secretly being 24 or anything really crazy like that.

by 














