Via Jim Bowden on Twitter:
JimBowdenXMFOX A.McCutcheon told us he loves the city of PG. He is open to being with Pirates for years to come.; had no comment if offered long term deal
This is extremely speculative but I find the "no comment" part to be interesting. He has been very open about not giving up free agent years in the past and if he hadn't been approached by the front office I don't see any reason why he wouldn't have just said "no." The debate on whether or not now is a good time to extend McCutchen has been exhausted on Bucs Dugout so I won't rehash it but I will say that if he is extended, and the Bucs are able to get a couple of free agent years in the process, I will be very happy.