Nate McLouth's Potential McReturn

I know that a lot of people groaned over seeing McLouth's name in the rumors yesterday, but I'd also like to think that a lot of of got a little twinge of excitment when we saw his name pop up.

Regardless, many people instantly became defensive saying this alludes to Jones being DFA'd since the two could probably put together similar years, if not Jones is better.

It seems to me though that this is more of a Derek Lee insurance policy. Let's be honest, once you get past Puljos and Fielder the first base market gets bleak rather quickly. I'd rather see the Pirates not do anything than sign another Overbay. (Though I admit, I thought Overbay was going to at least hold things together a bit better than he did.)

The Pirates have picked up Nick Evans, who's hit lefties pretty well, and have Garrett Jones, who as we all know can put a hurt to righties when he wants to.

I know a lot of us, if not most, HATE platoons, but honestly this seems like a decent one if anything. Sure, the defense is nothing to write home about, (Though they could possible shade Walker a few steps over to help since Barmes has pretty solid range going to his left.) but on paper they should hit well.

I know I'll get a lot of remarks about how Diaz and Jones didn't hit, but Evans is also six years younger than Diaz, and would appear to have some decent upside where you pretty much knew what you were getting with Diaz. Also, Jones could possibly hit better when he settles into one position, not worrying about two.

The point is, McLouth is probably being seen as a suitible lefty option on the bench, with the potential to bounce back if Presley stumbles.

Not the best plan out there, but not the worst. Just remember, with Derek Lee you're signing a player who's a lot closer to 40 than he appears, and you could very well get the Orioles rendition of Lee for the entire season.

I for one would rather see the platoon out there.