Chad Hermansen was the decisive winner for #3 in the poll. Results to date for most disappointing Pirates since Y2K are::

1. Andy LaRoche
2. Oliver Perez
3. Chad Hermansen

Since Tim Alderson hasn't received any support during the first three polls, I'm removing him from the voting list and adding Bryan Bullington. The voting list for #4 consists of Derek Bell, Bryan Bullington, Zach Duke, Adam Hyzdu, Akinori Iwamura, Dave Littlefield, Pat Meares, Brandon Moss, Tike Redman, and Ian Snell.

As usual, if your favorite for the #4 spot doesn't appear on the list, add the name under "Others" and include a +1.

If you would like to nominate additional candidates for the long list (posted in the #3 thread), please include them in the "Discussion" section.

We'll let this one run until Thursday morning.