Derek Bell edged out Ian Snell for the #4 slot on our list, which now consists of the following most disappointing Pirates since Y2K:

1. Andy LaRoche
2. Oliver Perez
3. Chad Hermansen
4. Derek Bell

Since they both received a vote in the #4 poll, I'm adding Brad Eldred and Jason Schmidt to the voting list (and removing Tike Redman). The voting list now consists of Bryan Bullington, Zach Duke, Brad Eldred, Adam Hyzdu, Akinori Iwamura, Dave Littlefield, Pat Meares, Brandon Moss, Jason Schmidt, and Ian Snell. Snell appears to be the favorite for the #5 slot, with Littlefield and Moss in the mix..... but the number of votes is small enough that anything could happen.

As usual, if your pick for #5 does not appear on the voting list, please add the name under "Others" along with your +1 vote.

I will post the list of the remaining previously-nominated candidates under "Discussion."