We have a consensus top five "most disappointing Pirates since Y2K," as follows:
I have removed Jason Schmidt from the "voting list" for the #6 slot and added John Van Benschoten. To vote for anyone on the voting list, just reply under that guy's name below with a +1 to indicate your vote. As always, if your favorite for the #6 slot is not on the voting list, just add the name under "Others" along with a +1 to indicate your vote.
Surprisingly, people are still being added to the candidates list, which now totals 44. Here is that list, with the guys on the voting list shown in bold:
House, J. R.
Van Benschoten, John
This poll will run until at least Sunday evening, and possibly Monday morning.