We have a consensus top five "most disappointing Pirates since Y2K," as follows:

1. Andy LaRoche
2. Oliver Perez
3. Chad Hermansen
4. Derek Bell
5. Ian Snell

I have removed Jason Schmidt from the "voting list" for the #6 slot and added John Van Benschoten. To vote for anyone on the voting list, just reply under that guy's name below with a +1 to indicate your vote. As always, if your favorite for the #6 slot is not on the voting list, just add the name under "Others" along with a +1 to indicate your vote.

Surprisingly, people are still being added to the candidates list, which now totals 44. Here is that list, with the guys on the voting list shown in bold:

Alderson, Tim
Alvarez, Pedro
Bautista, Jose
Benson, Kris
Bullington, Bryan
Burnett, Sean
Burnitz, Jeromy
Bradley, Bobby
Castillo, Jose
Clement, Jeff
Duffy, Chris
Duke, Zach
Eldred, Brad
Gorzelanny, Tom
Guillen, Jose
Hansen, Craig
Hill, Bobby
House, J. R.
Hyzdu, Adam
Iwamura, Akinori
LaRoche, Adam
Lincoln, Brad
Littlefield, Dave
Meares, Pat
Milledge, Lastings
Mondesi, Raul
Monroe, Craig
Morris, Matt
Morris, Warren
Moskos, Danny
Moss, Brandon
Ohlendorf, Ross
Paulino, Ron
Pearce, Steve
Ramirez, Aramis
Reboulet, Jeff
Redman, Tike
Russell, John
Santiago, Benito
Schmidt, Jason
Stynes, Chris
Tracy, Jim
Van Benschoten, John
Wells, Kip

This poll will run until at least Sunday evening, and possibly Monday morning.