Another tough one. Maholm was even better than his minor league numbers in the majors last year, but what does that mean? Let me know in the comments by guessing his 2006 innings pitched, strikeouts, walks and ERA.
Here are Maholm's major- and minor-league stats.
Kip Wells still needs votes.
| PLAYER | POS. | COMMUNITY | ZiPS |
| Ryan Doumit | C | .267/.334/.441 | .264/.327/.424 |
| Sean Casey | 1B | .300/.361/.446 | .313/.373/.441 |
| Jose Castillo | 2B | .275/.322/.441 | .277/.325/.394 |
| Jack Wilson | SS | .274/.316/.386 | .272/.314/.395 |
| Joe Randa | 3B | .275/.325/.399 | .277/.332/.440 |
| Jason Bay | LF | .298/.403/.547 | .297/.395/.557 |
| Chris Duffy | CF | .278/.331/.395 | .287/.338/.384 |
| Jeromy Burnitz | RF | .246/.317/.439 | .240/.311/.412 |
| PITCHER | IP | K | BB | ERA | ZiPS |
| Zach Duke | 191 | 127 | 49 | 3.53 | 181/117/42/3.73 |
| Oliver Perez | 160 | 160 | 72 | 4.15 | 152/180/74/4.32 |
Given that predicting Perez's performance is a huge crapshoot, it's surprising that the community and ZiPS are so similar here.